11-25-1987 Regular MeetingMIAMI SHORES VILLAGE
PENSION BOARD MEETING
The Village of Miami Shores Pension Board meeting was called to order by
Mayor Canton at 9:15 a.m. on Wednesday. November 25, 1987. (The meeting was
called to order at this late time due to the Special Council meeting that was
held). The following were in attendance:
Board Members:
Mayor Spero Canton
Sargeant Jack Ulmer
Ms. Patricia Varney
Dr. Robert Butler
Mr. William Wacker
Mr. Elly Johnson
Mr. William Heffernan
Also Present: Mr. Jim Linn of Carson & Linn,
Mr. Jim Rizzo of Kruse O'Connor
& Ling, Ms. Gail Macdonald - Plan
Administrator and Mr. William Fann
Village Attorney
Because of the late start of the meeting, Mr. Heffernan left at 9:00 a.m. and the
Board decided to revise the agenda upon Ms. Macdonald's request that the following
items be acted upon at this meeting:
1. Age Discrimination Issues
2. Participation as Amicus Curiae in Appeal of City of Orlando, etal
v. State of Florida etal.
3. Review motion re: Village Contribution in light of pending
referendum
4. Approval of 11/17/87 minutes
5. Adjournment
Dr. Butler made a motion to change the agenda per Ms. Macdonald's request. The
motion was seconded by Sargeant Ulmer.
4110 The motion passed unanimously.
1. Age Discrimination Issues
Mr. Jim Linn of Carson & Linn stated that since writing this letter of 9/10/87
the EEOC has issued proposed regulations indicating that any age - based
exclusions from a pension plan will no longer be permitted.
Jim Rizzo reported that there would be no material cost involved in lowering the
age limit to enter the Pension Plan. However, should the Board choose to remove
the upper age 55 limit, there is one major provision which should be included in
the Plan language. Those who had been hired at an age which previously precluded
them from joining the plan should be restricted from claiming any retroactive
credit. Mr. Rizzo suggested that the wording be similar to the following:
Employment credit will be effective from the date of the amendment forward, not
from age 21 or from date of employment.
• Or.Butler made a motion to eliminate the age requirement of 21 years of age and
the 55 year age limitation for enrollment into the Pension Plan.
Mr. Johnson seconded the motion.
The motion did not pass. The Board voted unanimously to oppose the motion as
stated.
Mr. Walker made a motion to eliminate the minimum age requirement on the Pension Plano
Mr. Johnson seconded the motion.
The motion passed unanimously.
2. Participation as Amicus Curiae in Appeal of City of Orlando, etal v. State
of Florida
Mr. Johnson made a motion that we do not enter the suit.
The motion died for lack of a second.
Mr. Walker made a motion that the Pension Board go on record as participating
in the Amicus Curiae brief and that we make the recommendation to the Village
Council that it also participate and that the cost of those participations be
borne by both bodies not to exceed $1250 each.
Sargeant Ulmer seconded the motion.
The motion passed with a four to one vote.(Mr. Johnson, Mayor Canton, Sargeant
Ulmer and Mr. Walker voded yea and Ms. Varney voted no).
3. Review motion re: Village Contribution in light of pending referendum.
The Board discussed the possibility of changing the 1 mill limitation by getting
the paper work started by the Village Attorney to prepare the ordinance for
change. The Village Charter must be changed by a referendum.. The Board suggested
to ask the Attorney General for an opinion so that the Charter can be changed to
exceed the 1 mill limitation. Mr. Johnson informed the Board that at the next
Council meeting that he will recommend to the Council to instruct the City Attorney
to start the preparation to put together the necessary ordinance for placement
on the ballot in March 1988.
4. Approval of 11/17/87 Minutes.
Mr. Johnson made a motion to approve the minutes of the 11/17/87 meeting.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Walker.
The motion passed unaminously.
5. Adjournment
Mr. Johnson made a motion to adjourn and reschedule the remainder of the
agenda for a future meeting.
The motion was seconded by Ms. Varney
The motion passed unaminously.
The meeting adjourned at 1015 a.m.
Elly . Jo on, Secretary
•