02-27-1995 Regular Meeting•
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
REGULAR MEETING
A regular meeting of the Miami Shores Village Historic Preservation
Board was held at Miami Shores Village Hall on Monday, February 27,
1995. The meeting was called to order at 7:30 p.m. by Vice
Chairperson Temkin, with the following members present:
Maria T. Temkin, Vice Chairperson
Margarita Courtney
Elaine Franck
Kimberly Logan -Hynes
Ms.
1.
Absent:
Warren von Bittner, Chairman
Temkin moved to add item 2A, 2B and 4A to the Agenda.
MINUTES - JANUARY 23, 1995
Ms. Logan -Hynes moved to approve the Minutes of the January 23,
1995 meeting as submitted. Ms. Courtney seconded the motion and it
passed unanimously.
2. REOUEST FOR HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION
21 N.W. 101st Street
Owner: Charles Smith
• Mr. Smith of 918 N.E. 92 Street was present to relate the historic
and architectural significance of the property in question. He
provided information regarding its builder and previous owners.
Mr. Smith indicated that the structure was still near its original
condition. A report on the history of the site was also presented,
prepared by Vice Chairperson Temkin. Board members discussed the
applicable criteria for determining the structure's Historic
Landmark Designation.
•
Member Franck
Council, which
taken and the
Courtney, aye;
a vote of 3 to
moved to recommend designation to the Village
was seconded by Member Logan -Hynes. Roll call was
board members voted as follows: Franck, aye;
Temkin, nay; and Hynes, aye. The motion passed by
1.
2A. APPLICATION FOR ADVISORY CERTIFICATE OF APPROPR ATENESS
Exterior Painting
21 N.W. 101st Street
Owner: Charles Smith
Mr. Smith of 918 N.E. 92 Street presented a request to paint the
exterior of the property in question in a four color scheme. One
color would be applied to the structure's slab, one to the walls,
one to the roof, and one to windows. After some discussion, Member
Franck suggested that the four color scheme might be overpowering
because of the home's simple design. The other board members
agreed. Mr. Smith agreed to defer his request for the Advisory
•
•
Certificate of HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD REGULAR MEETING
February 27, 1995
Page 2
Appropriateness in order to reconsider the paint scheme for the
exterior of the property in question.
2B. APPLICATION FOR ADVISORY CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Addition of Shutters
21 N.W. 101st Street
Owner: Charles Smith
Mr. Smith of 918 N.E. 92 Street presented a request to add wood
shutters to some of the windows at the property in question. Board
members discussed the issue and asked Mr. Smith to defer this
request, pending actual samples of the shutters proposed. Mr.
Smith agreed to defer his request for the Advisory Certificate of
Appropriateness.
3. APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Alteration - Paint gory grey cement roof tile white
374 N.E. 95th Street
Owners: Andrew and Toya Dubin
Ms. Dubin of 374 N.E. 95 Street was present to make the request to
paint the roof of the property in question. Ms. Dubin related to
board members what had transpired regarding the painting of her
roof. She had obtained a Historic Landmark Designation of her
property and was now ready to have her roof painted white, its
original color. The cement tile roof she had put on the structure
was grey in color. Member Logan -Hynes moved to approve the
Certificate of Appropriateness, which was seconded by Member
Courtney, and the motion passed unanimously.
4. ,APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Alteration - Enclose front porch with awning type windows
29 N.E. 91st Street
Owners: James Pruett and Steven C. Schmidt
Contractor: Bill Miranda, Supreme Aluminum Products
This item was deferred since the property's owners were not present
at the meeting.
4A. INFORMATIO ON THE IMPACT OF HISTORIC LANDMARK DES GNATION
TO A PROPERTY
Request from Sandy Winters
229 N.E. 101st Street
Sandy Winters of 229 N.E. 101 Street asked the board members about
the impact of historic landmark designation to a property. Ms.
Winters is considering purchasing a home which is historically
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD REGULAR MEETING
February 27, 1995
•
•
•
r •
Page 3
designated, but before she seriously considers the purchase wanted
to find out what types of alterations to the property would be
acceptable. Board members answered her questions, indicating that
the board works closely with owners of historic properties in order
to try and make reasonable suggestions regarding changes to a
property while considering its original condition.
5. WORDING FOR HISTORIC LANDMARK BRASS PLAOUE
374 N.E. 95th Street
Owners: Andrew and Toya Dubin
Board members consulted with Toya Dubin, the owner of the property
in question, regarding the wording of the brass plaque to be
ordered for her house. Board members and the owner agreed that the
wording for the Historic Landmark Brass Plaque for the property
should be the standard language and format that has been used for
previous plaques.
6. UPDATE ON THE MIAMI SHORES NEIGHBORHOOD SYMPOSIUM
Vice Chairperson Temkin announced that all the panelists for the
symposium had been selected and confirmed. The symposium was
scheduled to take place on March 14. Member Franck had submitted
and article for the Chamber of Commerce Newsletter regarding the
symposium and would also send a brochure announcing the symposium
to everyone on her mailing list.
7. ,AMENDMENT TO NATIONAL REGISTER THEMATIC GROUP I PROPOSAL -
CONSIDERATION OF POTENTIAL PROPERTIES
Member Logan -Hynes reported that she and Chairman Bittner had done
a site survey of properties with the potential of being included in
an amendment to the existing Miami Shores Thematic National
Register Nomination. A list of these properties will be submitted
to the board at a future meeting.
8. ANNOUNCEMENTS/COMMENTS
Vice Chairperson Temkin announced that some old magazines relating
to home and design had been donated to the board for their use to
be kept with the other historic materials in the trunk.
9. NEXT REGULAR MEETING
To be announced as necessary.
A motion for adjournment was made at 9:30 p.m.
Maria T. Temkin, Vice Chairperson