05-04-1995 Regular MeetingCODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING
May 4, 1995
A regular meeting of the Miami Shores Village Code Enforcement Board was held on
Thursday, May 4, 1995, at the Miami Shores Village Hall. The meeting was called to
order by Vice Chairperson Caldwell at 6:45 P.M. with the following members present:
Vice Chairperson Thomas J. Caldwell
Lance A. Harke
Margaret Burch
Prospero G. Herrera, 0
Ivor R. Hegedus
Absent: Barry Asmus
Also Present:
Bill Nelson
Richard Trumble
Amos Pierre
Vice Chairperson Caldwell called the meeting to order with the first item on the agenda
being the approval of the March 2, 1995, Minutes.
• 1. Minutes - March 2, 1995
Ms. Burch moved to approve the Minutes of March 2, 1995, as submitted. Mr.
Prospero seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
2. Vice Chairperson Caldwell asked the Secretary to swear in all parties who would
be giving testimony at the meeting.
3. The Secretary called the roll. Five members were present and one was absent.
HEARING
4. Case 4444
875 NE 93 Street
Owner: Gregory Hoffman and Rigoberto Martinez
Unauthorized construction/alterations
Section 6-4(a). Required.; Permits - Applications generally.
No person shall erect or construct or proceed with the erection or construction of
any building or structure, nor add to, enlarge, move, improve, alter, convert, extend or
demolish any building or structure, or any group of buildings and/or structures under
• one (1) or joint ownership whether on one or more lots or tracts of land; or cause the
same to be done where the cost of the work is one hundred dollars ($100) or more in
• Code Enforcement Board Regular Meeting
May 4, 1995
Page Two
value; and on any remodeling or alteration job of any value; without first obtaining a
permit therefor from the building department.
Mr. Martinez was present to speak on the violation. He stated that he had a
permit, and he thought the items in the violation were covered by the permit. Mr.
Nelson related the opinion of Mr. Lubian, Miami Shores Building Official, that the permit
was not considered valid because it did not follow the plan submitted.
Ms. Burch moved for a Finding of Fact and Conclusion of Law that a violation
exists to Section 6-4(a) of the Miami Shores Village Code and an administrative fee of
$180 be assessed. If the violation is not corrected within 30 days, a $25 a day fine hall
be levied. Mr. Prospero seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
5. Case No. 4475
1059 NE 104 Street
Owner: William L. McClausland
Unlawful roofing materials
• Section 225. Masonry construction.
Construction of all exterior walls and all structural elements of a building shall be
of stone, cement or cement products, brick or tile, and as further detailed in Chapter 27
of the South Florida Building Code. All roofs with inclines of not less than two and one-
half (2 1/2) inches per foot and all mansard facias shall be of the following materials:
(1) clay tile; (2) white concrete tile; (3) solid colored cement tile which color is
impregnated with the same color intensity throughout; (4) thick butt or variegated slate.
•
Mrs. Lilliana McClausland was present to speak on the violation. Mr. Trumble
explained to the Board that this was a new code violation written on March 3, 1995, for
no tiles on the roof. A permit had been issued in 1993. Ms. McClausland stated that
she had been short of money and would like to request another 30 days to have the
roof tiled.
Ms. Burch moved for a Finding of Fact and Conclusion of Law that a violation
exists to Section 225 of the Miami Shores Village Code and an administrative fee of
$180 be assessed. If the violation is not corrected within 30 days, a $25 a day fine
shall be levied. Mr. Harke seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
6. Case No. 4480
9817 North Miami Avenue
Owner: Rodrick Smith
Maintaining a nuisance
• Code Enforcement Board Regular Meeting
May 4, 1995
Page Three
Section 10-5. Maintaining source of noxious odors or gas, disturbing noise, or
other nuisance.
It shall be unlawful to maintain any source or cause of noxious odor or gas or of
any loud, disturbing noise or other nuisance, or to cause the same to exist.
Amos Pierre stated that the violation was written on March 23, 1995 for keeping
a dirty pool. He passed photographs for Board review. Mr. Pierre stated that on April
10 he contacted the representative and advised them of the pool condition and that it
had not been treated. He received a promise that the violation would be corrected. On
April 13 Mr. Pierre was told again that the violation would be corrected. Upon
reinspection, nothing had been done to the pool to correct the violation.
Mr. Hegedus moved for a Finding of Fact and Conclusion of Law that a violation
exists to Section 10-5 of the Miami Shores Village Code and an administrative fee of
$180 be assessed. If the violation is not corrected within 30 days, a $50 a day fine
shall be levied. Mr. Prospero seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
7. Case No. 4501
• 9450 NE 2 Avenue
Owner: James M. Breeding Estate
Tenant: Miami Shores Diner
Unsightly fascia, soffit, house exterior
Section 12-133. Depreciation of surrounding property.
The exterior of every structure shall be so maintained with reasonable
attractiveness so as not, in the case of excessive scaling or paint or excessive mildew,
to cause a substantial depreciation in property values in the immediate neighborhood.
The exterior surfaces shall be kept free from materials, objects and conditions which will
have an adverse effect on adjacent premises.
Ms. Samera Siddiqu was present to speak on the violation. Mr. Trumble stated
that orange paint was showing through on the green roof of the diner. He passed
pictures to the Board for review. Ms. Siddiqu had just requested a permit which had not
yet been given and asked the Board for a 30 day extension to paint and fix the roof.
Mr. Hegedus moved for a Finding of Fact and Conclusion of Law that a violation
exists to Section 12-133 of the Miami Shores Village Code and an administrative fee of
$180 be assessed. If the violation is not corrected within 30 days, a $25 a day fine
shall be levied. Ms. Burch seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
•
• Code Enforcement Board Regular Meeting
May 4, 1995
Page Four
8. Case No. 4502
9450 NE 2 Avenue
Owner: James M. Breeding Estate
Tenant: Miami Shores Diner
Section 12-133. Depreciation of surrounding property.
The exterior of every structure shall be so maintained with reasonable
attractiveness so as not, in the case of excessive scaling or paint or excessive mildew,
to cause a substantial depreciation in property values in the immediate neighborhood.
The exterior surfaces shall be kept free from materials, objects and conditions which will
have an adverse effect on adjacent premises.
Ms. Samera Siddiqu was present to speak on the violation. Mr. Trumble stated
that the trash area and enclosure was broken and falling apart. He passed pictures for
the Board to review. The picture showed the trash area having been pieced together
and Mr. Trumble determined that this was not acceptable. He stated that he had told
the tenant that a chain Zink fence would be appropriate. This had not been done as of
yet. Ms. Siddiqu stated that she would have the trash area fixed and enclosed properly
• if she could have a 30 day extension. Vice Chairperson Caldwell stated he believed
another $180 administrative fee should not be assessed on this property if the 30 day
extension were given.
•
Ms. Burch moved for a Finding of Fact and Conclusion of Law that a violation
exists to Section 12-133 of the Miami Shores Village Code and if the violation was not
corrected within 30 days, a $25 a day fine shall be levied. Mr. Harke seconded the
motion and it passed unanimously.
9. Case No. 4497
334 NE 102 Street
Owner: Cesar A. Jofre
General unsightliness
Section 10-1. Property to be maintained in safe, clean and sightly condition.
It shall be the duty of all owners of lots, parcels and tracts of land within the
village to keep such property in a safe, clean and sightly condition and to remove
therefrom all surplus grass, weeds and other growth and all trash and rubbish and to fill
in all excavations and depressions thereon.
No one was present to speak about the violation. Mr. Trumble passed pictures
to the Board for review. He stated that the home and land were kept in a very unsightly
manner. The lawn would be mowed but never trimmed. Mr. Trumble stated that only
• Code Enforcement Board Regular Meeting
May 4, 1995
Page Five
•
•
one neighbor had complained and this complaint was given after he had served a
violation upon them. The owners had recently pulled a permit to paint the house.
Mr. Prospero moved for a Finding of Fact and Conclusion of Law that a violation
exists to Section 10-1 of the Miami Shores Village Code and an administration fee of
$180 be assessed. If the violation is not corrected within 30 days, a $25 a day fine
shall be levied. Mr. Hegedus seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
10. Case No. 4504
1079 NE 96 Street
Owner: Susan Gilbert
General unsightliness
Section 10-1. Property to be maintained in safe, clean and sightly condition.
It shall be the duty of all owners of lots, parcels and tracts of land within the
village to keep such property in a safe, clean and sightly condition and to remove
therefrom all surplus grass, weeds and other growth and all trash and rubbish and to fill
in all excavations and depressions thereon.
Mr. Trumble stated that the violation had been corrected. Ms. Burch moved for
dismissal. Mr. Prospero seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
11. Code Enforcement Six Month Statistical Report
Mr. Nelson was at the Board Meeting to present the Code Enforcement Six
Month Statistical Report.
12. Adjournment.
Ms. Burch made a motion to adjourn. Mr. Prospero seconded the motion and it
passed unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 7:00 p.m.
Vice C _:.:.•ers n
II,
4111Prf J fI1
• Ann Ragon'7'c`