06-22-2004 Special MeetingBarbara Estep, CMC
VILLAGE CLERK
MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE
Office of the Village Clerk
10050 N.E.2nd Avenue
Miami Shores, Florida 33138
Tel: (305) 795.2207
Fax: (305) 756.8972
E-mail: EsteDB(CD.MiamiShoresVillage.com
MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING/PUBLIC HEARING
The Miami Shores Village Council held a Special Council Meeting and Public Hearing on Tuesday, June 22, 2004
at the C. Lawton McCall Community Center. The meeting was called to order at 7:00 PM with the following
individuals in attendance:
PRESENT: Jim McCoy
Herta Holly
Al Davis
Ed Quinton
Greg Ullman
ALSO PRESENT: Tom Benton, Village Manager
Barbara Estep, Village Clerk
Richard Sarafan, Village Attorney
Village Department Head Staff
ACTION ITEMS
1) COUNCIL DISCUSSION REGARDING THE ANNEXATION OF AN AREA OF
UNINCORPORATED MIAMI-DADE COUNTY ADJACENT TO BARRY UNIVERSITY AND
NORTHWEST OF MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE.
Mr. Benton offered general background information related to the annexation process and the specific area
involved in the boundary change proposal. Mr. Benton relayed information regarding a portion of the
County's Code that regulates annexations and which addresses areas which contain less than 250 qualified
electors and are less than 50% residentially developed. It was discovered late this afternoon that this section of
the County Code may apply to this particular proposal and an election may need to be held prior to the
annexation being voted upon by the County Commission. This is a substantial change in the information and
assumptions under which the Village has been proceeding. Mr. Benton reported that the Village
Administration is still researching the matter and regardless of the outcome, the Public Hearing and subsequent
Resolution is required prior to moving forward with the annexation application process.
2) PUBLIC HEARING REGARDING THE PROPOSEDANNEXATION.
• Mayor McCoy opened the Public Hearing to hear comments regarding the proposed annexation.
David Smitherman
570 NW 112th St
•
Lyn Sammuli
510-512 NW 113th St
Thelma Komo
11230 NW 5th Ave.
Michelle Haziza
164 NE 105th St
James Warner
515 NW 115th St
Cauvin Cadet
579 NW 111th St
•
Mr. Smitherman expressed his opinion that the proposal is a good idea
and asked for clarification regarding the affected area and how Village
Codes and standards will be applied, i.e. tile roofs.
Mr. Benton and Mr. Sarafan spoke of allowing time for properties to meet
the standards of the Village, with Mr. Sarafan indicating that timelines will
be developed should the annexation be approved by the County.
Mr. Sammuli spoke of the Village's codes as they may relate to the duplex
unit that he owns within the affected area. Mr. Sammuli spoke of the
increase in taxes and also asked for clarification regarding the flat roof that
is on the dwelling.
Mr. Curtis Craig, the Village's Building Director, advised Mr. Sammuli of
the information contained within the Florida Building Code as it relates to
pitched roofs. The Village Administration reiterated that if certain criteria is
met, a variance from the existing Village code requirements may be granted.
Ms. Komo asked about the mechanism to ensure that a verbatim transcript of
the meeting would be available. She then stated that she owns property in
the affected area and that she was looking for information relating to the
Village's codes, how the codes would be applied to the annexed area and
what time frames would be used to come into compliance. Ms. Komo also
asked about fees and fines related to code violations.
Mr. Sarafan responded to Ms. Komo's questions relating to code
enforcement, outlining the process and indicating that violations are brought
before the Code Enforcement Board for hearings and adjudication.
Ms. Haziza is a current Miami Shores resident and asked for the rational for
wanting to annex the area.
Individual Council Members responded to Ms. Haziza's question, expressing
their personal views on the proposal.
Mr. Warner asked about the tax implications of the annexation.
After clarifying Mr. Warner's address, Mr. Benton advised Mr. Warner that
his property was not affected by the proposed annexation. However, Mr.
Benton did indicate to those present in the audience of the possible tax
implications should the annexation be approved. Mr. Benton stated that the
Village is still in the process of developing the upcoming fiscal year budget
and cannot state with certainty what next year's millage rate will be.
Mr. Cadet asked about his water bill and whether it would remain with the
County and billed every three months. He also asked for information
relating to his shingle roof.
Mr. Benton indicated that there would be no change in the water service
provided to the affected area as the Village is also billed through Miami -
Dade County Water & Sewer Department. Mayor McCoy reiterated the
earlier response regarding code/roof questions.
Jean Weeks
560 NW 112t St
Ms. Weeks asked about the assessment on her home and whether that would
change should the annexation be approved.
Mr. Benton and Mr. Davis advised that the County would continue to assess
the value of her property but that different tax rates would be applied to the
value if the annexation is approved.
Elizabeth Archer Ms. Archer does not live in the proposed annexation area but asked if there
515 NW 115th St were any future plans to annex the area where she lives.
Mayor McCoy stated that there are no plans currently being discussed.
Lisa Bailey-Smitherman Ms. Bailey-Smitherman asked about when the tax bills would be mailed out
570 NW 112th St and payment due.
Mr. Benton advised that the tax billing cycle would be the same as with the
current County system as the Village's tax information would be contained
on the County bill as a new line item.
Lyn Summali Mr. Summali asked for clarification regarding the location of the new charter
510-512 NW 113th St school and it's correlation to the annexation proposal.
As no one else present wished to comment on the proposed boundary change/annexation, Mayor McCoy
closed the Public Hearing.
3) POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING ADOPTING A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI SHORES
VILLAGE COUNCIL, APPROVING THE INITIATION OF A PROPOSED MUNICIPAL
BOUNDARY CHANGE PURSUANT TO SECTION 20-3, MIAMI-DADE COUNTY CODE OF
ORDINANCES.
Following a suggestion from Mr. Ullman, Mr. Sarafan pointed out that the western limit of the proposed
boundary change needed to be corrected to include the property west to Interstate 95 but not to include the
Department of Transportation's right-of-way. Mr. Ullman, Mrs. Holly and Mayor McCoy made brief
comments regarding the proposal and the Resolution before them. Mr. Davis moved to adopt the proposed
Resolution as amended. Mr. Ullman seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
4) ADJOURNMENT
The June 22, 2004 Special Council Meeting/Public Hearing was adjourned at 7:52 PM.
Barbara A. Estep, CMC
Village Clerk
•
Jim McCoy, Mayor