06-04-2002 Regular Meeting•
•
MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
The Miami Shores Village Council held it's regular Council Meeting on Tuesday, June 4,
2002 at the Village Hall. The meeting commenced at 7:30 PM with the following
members present:
PRESENT:
Mayor Davis
Greg Ullman
Bob Blum
Prospero Herrera
Mark Ulmer
ALSO PRESENT: Tom Benton, Village Manager
Barbara Fugazzi, Village Clerk
Richard Sarafan, Village Attorney
PRESENTATION
Al Berg, Planning & Zoning/Code Enforcement Director, presented a certificate to Edwin
Lopez and Tim LeBel in honor of their home being named "House of the Month" for the
month of June, 2002.
Mr. Ullman arrived at this time.
CONSIDERATIONS
1) MINUTES Barbara A. Fugazzi
A) APPROVAL OF THE MAY 21, 2002 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES.
Mr. Herrera moved to approve the May 21, 2002 Regular Council Meeting Minutes. Mr.
Blum seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous in favor.
2) VILLAGE MANAGER Tom Benton
A) DISCUSSION OF ACCEPTANCE OR REJECTION OF THE PROPOSED
CHANGE OF CONTROL AND INTERNAL RESTRUCTUING OF AT&T
CORPORATION, THE VILLAGE'S CABLE TELEVISION PROVIDER.
Following a request from AT&T Broadband and at the suggestion of Mr. Sarafan, Mr.
Ulmer moved to table the matter until the July 2, 2002 Council Meeting with the express
• understanding that the July 2, 2002 meeting is within the 120 day window prescribed by
Federal Law for this consideration to be heard. Mr. Herrera seconded the motion and the
vote was unanimous in favor.
•
•
B) DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING THE 95TH
STREET AND GRAND CONCOURSE TRAFFIC REPORT AND
PROPOSED ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS.
Mr. Benton provided background information on the issue and indicated that the issues to
be addressed are: 1) Does the Council want to fund the improvements for 95th Street. 2)
If so, to what extent, Modified Version D or something more/less. Mr. Benton indicated
that he has included funding at $100,000 per year in the proposed 5 year capital budget
for the improvements to Grand Concourse.
For discussion purposes, Mr. Ullman moved that the Village implement Version D with
the exceptions 1-3 outlined in the Village Manager's back-up memorandum. Mr. Herrera
seconded the motion.
Individual Council members expressed their thoughts on the proposal, addressing such
issues as solving one street's problems only to create a similar problem for another street;
funding limitations, and whether or not the matter is one of beautification or safety, and
that perhaps better enforcement of the traffic laws was needed.
Mr. Ulmer moved to table Mr. Ullman's motion and discuss improvements to Grand
Concourse first. Mayor Davis seconded the motion. The vote was 3-2 with Mr. Ullman
and Mr. Herrera dissenting.
Mr. Ulmer moved to adopt the Village Manager's Grand Concourse improvement
recommendations to construct medians and knuckles from N.E. 2nd Avenue to N.E. 6th
Avenue to be constructed by the Village Public Works Department and funded by Local
Option Gas Tax dollars dependent upon approval of the proposed five year capital
budget. The project should be completed in three phases: 1) paint striping of medians
and knuckles from N.E. 2nd to N.E. 6th Avenues; 2) construct the medians and knuckles;
and 3) landscaping of the medians and knuckles. The Manager should report back to the
Council with a landscaping plan and additionally, assess the feasibility of installing speed
humps and/ or stop signs. Mayor Davis seconded the motion.
Council members discussed variations of Mr. Ulmer's motion, with a major concern
being committing to spending dollars from the capital budget when the capital budget has
not yet been presented. Mr. Blum suggested an amendment to Mr. Ulmer's motion
which would be to immediately stripe the medians and knuckles on Grand Concourse and
install speed humps on N.E. 95th Street. Mr. Ulmer and Mayor Davis accepted the
amendment. Mayor Davis opened the floor for public comment.
Dan Dower
Mr. Dower spoke of the traffic volume and speed of vehicles
driving along N.E. 95th Street. He endorsed the Village
Manager's plan for the roadway.
Terry Cusan Mr. Cusan indicated his support of Mr. Benton's plan and further
• suggested installing four way stops signs along Grand Concourse.
James Fee
Mr. Fee expressed his belief that Grand Concourse is a defective
roadway and that 95th Street is an enforcement issue. He urged
the Council to look at the larger traffic issue as the cars will go to
another street and create new problems.
Jan Rayburn Ms. Rayburn spoke about the possibility of starting the striping of
the medians and knuckles at both ends of Grand Concourse rather
than starting at one end and working north or south.
Jim McCoy Mr. McCoy indicated that shifting the burden of traffic to other
streets would cause additional problems. He asked the Council to
consider the implications.
Ralph Rayburn Mr. Rayburn spoke of the traffic problems on Grand Concourse.
Donald Shockey Mr. Shockey stated that speed humps on 95th Street would be a
significant improvement.
T. F. Chambers Mr. Chambers suggested putting up signs like Biscayne Park.
Donna Hurtak Ms. Hurtak spoke of the traffic at Grand Concourse and N.E. 6th
Avenue. She suggested the possibility of using rumble strips to
slow traffic.
Mayor Davis closed public comment. Mr. Ulmer re -stated the amended motion, moving
to have the Village proceed immediately with the striping of medians and knuckles on
Grand Concourse and install speed humps on N.E. 95th Street and review the availability
of capital funding with an eye towards completing the modified Version D plan for N.E.
95th Street. Mayor Davis seconded the amended motion. Mr. Blum verified that
everything proposed would need Miami -Dade County approval. Mayor Davis called for
the vote which was unanimous in favor of the motion.
3) VILLAGE COUNCIL
A) DISCUSSION REGARDING AMENDING THE VILLAGE'S GENERAL
EMPLOYEE PENSION PLAN. Greg Ullman
Mr. Ullman briefly outlined the purpose of his placing this item on the agenda,
highlighting the fact that the Village's employee pension plan is not competitive with
other municipalities. Following a request by the Mayor, Mr. Ullman moved to discuss
amending the pension plan criteria to allow for a 30 year and out clause. Mr. Ulmer
seconded the motion. Mr. Ullman requested that Mark Malatak, the Village's Finance
Director, review the components of the plan. Mr. Malatak provided the Council with
information regarding the proposed plan, indicating that the amendment would move the
Village's pension benefit more in line with what other municipalities offer. The
proposal would allow for employees who started their careers at an early age work 30
years and retire, regardless of their age. As the plan is currently structured, the
employees would have to wait until age 62 before their benefits would begin.
3
•
•
•
The Village Clerk confirmed that the item would need to come before the Council in the
form of an amending Ordinance and that tonight's action would only be to approve of the
concept of amending the pension plan.
Mr. Ullman amended his motion and moved to instruct staff to prepare an ordinance
which would provide for a 30 year and out pension benefit clause. Mr. Herrera seconded
the motion and the vote was unanimous in favor.
B) DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING A REQUEST TO
CLOSE THE ALLEY BETWEEN N.W. 95TH & N.W. 96TH STREET, JUST
WEST OF NORTH MIAMI AVENUE. Prospero Herrera
Mr. Herrera explained the problem of traffic cutting through the alley. He indicated that
one of the property owners, Mr. Forero had obtained the signatures of his neighbors and
is requesting that the Village chain the alleyway. Mr. Herrera moved to direct staff to
close the alleyway between N.W. 95th and N.W. 96th Streets, just west of North Miami
Avenue. Mayor Davis seconded the motion. Following clarification on the location of
the alleyway and Mr. Benton's concurrence with the request, Mayor Davis called for the
vote which was unanimous in favor.
4) ANNOUCEMENTS
The Clerk read the announcements.
5) PUBLIC COMMENTS
Ann Fernandez Ms. Fernandez spoke of her concerns regarding the proposed
charter school.
Jan Rayburn Thanked the Council for their actions relating to Grand Concourse.
Bill Cate
Mr. Cate spoke of the proposed charter school and asked that the
Council look at everything carefully and ask whether its worth the
risk.
6) COUNCIL COMMENTS
Mr. Ullman Mr. Ullman announced the Council Workshop session scheduled
for Wednesday, June 5.
No Comment
No Comment
Mr. Ulmer
Mr. Blum
Mr. Herrera
Mr. Herrera congratulated the "Home of the Month" recipients and
thanked the residents of Grand Concourse and N.E. 95th Street for
their attendance.
•
•
•
Mayor Davis Mayor Davis spoke of the Memorial Day program.
7) ADJOURNMENT
The June 4, 2002 Council Meeting was adjourned at 9:00 PM
)6' G1�".
Barbara A. Fugazzi,
Village Clerk
5
Davis, Mayor