07-03-1990 Regular Meeting MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
JULY 3, 1990
The regular meeting of the Miami Shores Village Council
was held on Tuesday, July 3, 1990 at Village Hall commencing
at 7:33 p.m. with the following members present :
Mayor Courtney
Herb Spahn
Stephen Loffredo
Marty Stofik
Absent : Spero Canton
Also present : Gail Macdonald
William F . Fann.
ITEM *1 MINUTES
Ms. Stofik moved approval of the minutes from the Regular
Council meeting of 6/19/90. Mr . Spahn seconded the motion and
the vote was unanimous . in favor . Mayor Courtney acknowledged
receipt of the following minutes:
Pension Board 5/25/90
Planning and Zoning Board 6/14/90
ITEM *2 PRESENTATION OF THE FORTY-SECOND ANNUAL REPORT FROM THE
BROCKWAY MEMORIAL LIBRARY. Mr . James Stuart delivered the
report . He reviewed the statistics for the Library for the
year . He stated that the success of the Library is mostly due
to the fine staff under the leadership of Ms. Kelly and Ms.
Esper .
ITEM *3 REQUEST TO APPROVE ASSIGNMENT OF COUNTRY CLUB FOOD AND
BEVERAGE SERVICES. Ms. Macdonald explained the background
stating that the contract with Total Food Service Direction
(TFSD) Is a sublease and needs Council approval to be
Implemented. Mr . Chuck Hart, Country Club Manager , stated that
TFSD is much more qualified than PCM to run the food service at
the Club. He said that a lease was preferable because of the
purchasing power of TFSD and the use of their personnel . Mr .
Hart said TFSD will be leasing the entire food and beverage
service including the Snack Shack . He said that pricing and for
existing banquet contracts will remain in effect . Mayor
Courtney asked how many personnel will be affected. Mr . Hart
replied about 40 people. Mr . Gus Gregory, President of TFSD,
spoke about his firms experience In the food business. ' Mr .
Spahn stated that TFSD has been in place at the Club since April
and have a good
reputation in the business. Mr . Ed Abdelia asked how contracting
with TFSD would effect prices at the Club. Mr . Hart replied
that TFSD would have no Input for fees to members. Mr . Spahn
moved to approve the assignment as a sublease of the Country
Club food and beverage services from PCM to TFSD. Ms. Stofik
seconded the motion . Mayor Courtney stated that he was
concerned that all questions have not been answered regarding
the notes to the financial statements. Mr . Loffredo stated that
TFSD runs a quality operation; however , he wants the questions
raised by Mayor Courtney answered before a decision is made.
Mr . Loffredo moved to table the Item until the next meeting.
Ms. Stofik seconded the motion and the vote was as follows:
Loffredo - Yes
Courtney - Yes
Stofik - Yes
Spahn - No
ITEM *4 RESOLUTION OF MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE COUNCIL SUPPORTING
ESTABLISHMENT OF MULTI-GOVERNMENT TASK FORCE FOR STUDY OF AREA
BETWEEN N.E . 85TH STREET AND N.E . 91ST STREET, BORDERED ON THE
WEST BY BISCAYNE BOULEVARD AND ON THE EAST BY N.E . 10TH AVENUE .
Mayor Courtney read the caption of the resolution and Ms.
Macdonald explained the background . Mr . Loffredo asked who will
be on the Task Force and how will they be appointed . Mayor
Courtney explained that he will appoint the members and that he
Is looking for Interested volunteers. Mr . Loffredo suggested
that the Council adopt the list of appointments. Mr . Loffredo
moved approval of the resolution of Miami Shores Village Council
supporting establishment of Multi -government Task Force for the
study of the area specified on the agenda. Mr . Spahn seconded
the motion . Ms. Stofik asked to whom the Task Force would take
their recommendations. Mayor Courtney replied to the City of
Miami , Dade County, Dade County School Board and Miami Shores.
Mr . Loffredo stated that the Task Force will report to the
Council . Mr . Fann stated that they will make their
recommendations to those who establish the Task Force. Ms.
Stofik asked who is in charge of the Task Force. Mr . Spahn
stated that the Council has to appoint a leader and suggested
Ms. Macdonald. Mayor Courtney reviewed the list of possible
appointees to the Task Force. The vote was unanimous in favor .
ITEM *5 APPOINTMENT OF TASK FORCE MEMBERS
Mayor Courtney stated that the other entities have already
appointed their members of the task force and their names are
Included In the list . Mr . Loffredo stated that he has a problem
with requiring Ms. Macdonald to be the chairperson of the Task
Force. He suggested Father McLaughlin or some other member .
Mr . Spahn stated the Council should give the leadership that was
requested and appoint a chairman. Ms. Stofik stated she has a
problem with appointing a Village employee as chairman because
the area in question is mostly out of the Shores and is a
citizen initiative. Mayor Courtney stated he would like to
appoint : Ellen Wacher , Ward Barritt, Prospero Herrerra,
Randy Atlas, Richard Colangelo, Michael Nelson,
Jacqueline Scott, David Bonilla, Richard Haft,
BIII Waters, Dottie Yates, Nancy Gorski ,
Robert Lordy, John Militana, Father McLaughlin,
Harriet Gilbreath, Michael McNeal , Carol Cortez,
Gail Macdonald or her designee
and have Harriet Gilbreath be the Chairman. Mr . Spahn suggested
that Father McLaughlin chair the first meeting and let them
choose their own chairman . Ms. Harriet Gilbreath stated that
the Citizens need action now, not a year from now. She related
a bad incident that happened recently. Mr . Loffredo suggested
Chief Zoovas Instead of Ms. Macdonald. Ms. Macdonald stated that
Chief Zoovas would have been her designee. Mr . Brian Geenty
suggested that people who live in the area be appointed to the
Task Force. Father McLaughlin stated that he would co-chair the
first meeting with Harriet Gilbreath and that he would like to
have the group choose their own chairman. He said that the
chairman must be powerful not just for show. Mr . Fann stated
that if Miami Shores appoints the members of the Committee then
It will only be a Miami Shores Committee. He said that this
resolution should be given to the City of Miami and Dade County
so they can adopt their own resolutions. Mayor Courtney stated
that It would take too long to take that route. Ms. Stofik
stated that the Task Force could get recommendations in process
at the first meeting. She said that the success of the Task
force will be determined by the follow-up of the members. Mr .
Spahn moved that the Council accept the Mayor 's appointments for
the Task Force. Mr . Loffredo seconded the motion and the vote
was unanimous in favor . Mayor Courtney asked Ms. Macdonald to
send out notices to the members and set up a meeting in the next
three weeks.
ITEM *6 RESOLUTION OF MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE COUNCIL EXPRESSING
OPPOSITION TO ERECTION OF PROPOSED STATE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL "V"
ON LESS THAN ELEVEN ( 11 ) ACRES OF GROUND. Mayor Courtney read
the caption of the resolution and Ms. Macdonald explained the
background . Ms. Stofik suggested wording the resolution to ask
the School Board to proceed as quickly as possible. Mr . Spahn
stated that the Council wants the school and will accept 4.7
acres If that is all we can get . Mr . Loffredo stated that the
School Board is under severe budget constraints and this
resolution may result in the postponement of building the
school . He suggested reworking the proposal to Include off site
parking . Ms. Stofik suggested wording the resolution to read:
The Council wishes to encourage the Dade County School Board to
Proceed Immediately with the construction of State School V and
urge you to acquire as much additional property as possible
toward the goal of 11 acres. Mayor Courtney agreed . He said
the Council should try not to break down any bridges that have
been built between the School Board and Miami Shores. Mr .
Loffredo suggested that the 11 acre standard not be In the
motion. He said that if the School Board bought very bad
properties adjacent to the new school it would benefit them and
the community. Ms. Stofik stated that It would be good to bring
up Mr . Loffredo's Idea at the first Task Force meeting. Mr .
Spahn moved to table the Item and allow Mr . Loffredo to work
with Mr . Fann to rework the resolution and bring It up at the
next meeting . Ms. Stoflk seconded the motion. Mr . Fann asked
that the minutes reflect the Council 's desires regarding the
resolution. The vote was unanimous in favor . Ms. Stofik spoke
about the addition to Miami Shores Elementary School .
ITEM *7
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 270, AS AMENDED;
DEFINING AND PERMITTING ADULT CONGREGATE LIVING FACIL-
ITIES AND COMMUNITY RESIDENTIAL HOMES; DEFINING DEVELOP-
MENT ORDER, DEVELOPMENT PERMIT, DRAINAGE FACILITIES,
LEVEL OF SERVICE, PLAT AND SUBDIVISION; DEFINING AND
AUTHORIZING PRO PLANNED RESIDENTIAL-OFFICE DISTRICT;
ESTABLISHING RATIO OF FLOOR AREA TO LOT AREA IN A-1 AND
A-2 DISTRICTS; ESTABLISHING REQUIRED YARD AREA PERVIOUS
TO RAINFALL; REQUIRING IMMEDIATE DISPOSAL OF DEFINED
HAZARDOUS WASTE; INCREASING MINIMUM STANDARD FOR SIGNS;
ADDING 100-YEAR FLOOD ELEVATION IN FEMA MAP TO DETERMINE
MINIMUM FIRST FLOOR JOIST LEVEL; RESTRICTING LOCATION
OF ENTRANCES AND EXITS AND REQUIRING LANDSCAPING THEREOF
REQUIRING PARKING LOT DESIGN TO CONTROL FLOW OF INTERNAL
TRAFFIC; ESTABLISHING REQUIREMENT FOR LAND SUBDIVISION;
ESTABLISHING MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR ON-SITE DRAINAGE
AND NEW SEPTIC TANKS; ESTABLISHING NEW SETBACK REQUIRE-
MENTS ON DEFINED ARTERIAL OR COLLECTOR STREETS; PROHIBITING
FILLING EXISTING LAKES; REQUIRING SPECIAL APPROVAL OF NEW
DEVELOPMENT ON BISCAYNE BAY; REQUIRING SIDEWALKS FOR NEW
CONSTRUCTION; INCREASING FACTORS TO BE CONSIDERED BY
COUNCIL IN CASE OF SPECIAL APPROVAL; REQUIRING ALL
DEVORDERS BE CONSISTENT WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLAN;
CONDITIONING NEW DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL ON MEETING MINIMUM
LEVELS OF SERVICE REQUIRED BY A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND
EXEMPTING CERTAIN LANDS THEREFROM; ESTABLISHING DADE COUNTY
CONCURRENCY INFORMATION CENTER AND METROPOLITAN DADE COUNTY
ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER NUMBER 4-85 AS SOURCES OF FACILITY
CAPACITIES; ESTABLISHMENT OF MEASURING CAPACITY OF
WATER-LINES AND HIGHWAYS, CALCULATING SOLID WASTE
GENERATION RATES, DRAINAGE AND RECREATION; ESTABLISHING
METHOD FOR DETERMINATION OF CAPACITY AVALABILITY;
ESTABLISHING BURDEN OF SHOWING COMPLIANCE ON APPLICANT;
ESTABLISHING RESPONSIBILITY OF MONITORING ON DIRECTOR OF
BUILDING AND ZONING; ESTABLISHING DEADLINE FOR CONCURRENCY
DETERMINATION; ESTABLISHING AN EXEMPTION DATE FOR
DEVELOPMPROVIDING EFFECTIVE DATE. SECOND
AND FINAL READING. Ms. Macdonald read the caption of the
ordinance and explained the background . Mr . Spahn moved for
adoption. Ms. Stofik seconded the motion and the vote was
unanimous in favor .
ITEM *8 COUNCIL ADOPTION OF MIAMI SHORES DRUG TESTING POLICY.
Ms. Macdonald explained the background and recommended approval .
Mr . Spahn so moved . Mr . Loffredo seconded the motion and the
vote was unanimous In favor .
ITEM *9 ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mayor Courtney read the announcements.
ITEM *10 COUNCIL COMMENTS
Ms. Stofik spoke about the newsletter and the 4th of July.
Mr . Spahn spoke about the food operation at the Country Club.
Mr . Loffredo spoke about property values of Miami Shores.
Mayor Courtney spoke about barricades and showed examples of
possible signs for the entrance of Miami Shores.
Ms. Macdonald stated that the Village has been successful In
getting a grant of $25,680 for the beautification of Biscayne
Boulevard .
ITEM *11 PUBLIC COMMENTS
Mr . Ed Abdelia asked about TFSD.
Mr . Condit spoke about barricades.
ITEM *12 ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 9: 12 pm.
Henry Courtne
Mayor
Attest : Gail Macdonald
Village Clerk
By !�
Scott W. Davis
Deputy Village Clerk