06-20-1989 Regular MeetingMIAMI SHORES VILLAGE
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
JUNE 20, 1989
The regular meeting of the Miami Shores Village Council
was held on Tuesday, June 20, 1989 at Village Hall commencing
at 7:30 p.m. with the following members present:
Mayor Henry T. Courtney
Herb Spahn
Spero Canton
Stephen Loffredo
Marty Stofik
Also present: Elly F. Johnson
William F. Fann
Pastor John Hirst from the Redeemer Lutheran Church gave
the invocation and Mayor Courtney led the Pledge of
Allegiance.
ITEM *1 MINUTES
Ms. Stofik moved approval of the minutes from the Regular
Council meeting of 6/6/89. Mr. Canton seconded the motion and
the vote was unanimous In favor.
Mr. Loffredo asked that " The reason that the Duffy group
came to the Council Is because of the perceived effect that
they felt Phase 1 would have on them" be added to the minutes
from the Barricade Workshop of 5/30/89. Ms. Stofik moved
approval of the minutes from the Barricade Workshop with the
changes mentioned by Mr. Loffredo. Mr. Canton seconded the
motion and the vote was unanimous In favor.
Mayor Courtney acknowledged receipt of the following minutes:
Ad -Hoc Task Force on Sewers 5/25/89
Country Club Advisory Board 5/31/89
Code Enforcement Board 6/1/89
Planning And Zoning Board 6/8/89
ITEM *2 APPOINTMENT TO THE DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION BOARD AND
THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD. Mr. Johnson explained the
procedure for filling a board position. Mr. Alfred J. Tirella
gave his reasons for seeking a position on the Downtown
Revitalization Board. Mr. Spahn suggested delaying the
selection for 30 days to review the mix of board members. Ms.
Pat Dahne stated that the board currently has no attorneys as
board members. Mr. Spahn withdrew his suggestion. Mr. Spahn
moved to appoint Mr. Tirella to the Downtown Revitalization
Board. Mr. Loffredo seconded the motion and the vote was
unanimous in favor. Mayor Courtney turned the meeting over to
Mr. Spahn and left the room because his wife was a candidate
for the vacant position on the Historic Preservation Board.
Mr. Loffredo moved to appoint Ms. Margarita R. Courtney to the
Historic Preservation Board. Mr. Canton seconded the motion
and the vote was as follows:
Mr. Spahn Yes
Mr. Loffredo Yes
Mr. Canton Yes
Ms. Stofik No
Ms. Courtney's appointment passed.
ITEM *3 RESOLUTION AMENDING THE RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING
CURRENT COUNTRY CLUB FEE AND USE REGULATIONS, BEING RESOLUTION
NO. 820-87; AUTHORIZING NON RESIDENT COUNTRY CLUB MEMBERS TO
USE VILLAGE SWIMMING POOL UPON PAYMENT OF DAILY USER FEE.
Mayor Courtney read the title of the resolution. Mr.
Spahn asked about Section 2(a). Mr. Fann stated that the
Council should voice their opinion at the meeting and he would
make any changes the Council desires. Ms. Stofik moved
approval of the resolution with the following change to section
2(a): All memberships Include Clubhouse privileges and also
include swimming pool privileges upon the payment of
the daily guest rate user fee.
Mr. Canton seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous In
favor.
ITEM *4 LIBRARY ANNUAL REPORT. Mr. James Stuart, President of
the Board of Trustees for the Brockway Memorial Library,
reviewed the 41st annual report. Mr. Canton stated the board
and staff have done an outstanding Job at the library. Mr.
Loffredo complimented Mr. Stuart on the new non-fiction
selection. Mr. Stuart replied that Ms. Esper the Librarian
does a terrific Job In selecting those books.
ITEM *5 AWARD OF BID FOR STREET PAVING. Mr. Johnson
recommended Pan American Construction Company do the paving In
the budgeted amount of $137,400. Mr. Spahn asked for an
updated list of which streets are to be paved. Mr. Tom Benton
distributed a list of streets to be paved In this project. Mr.
Benton stated he personally surveys the streets and alleys In
Miami Shores and makes up the paving list from his observations.
Mr. Loffredo inquired why there Is a difference this year
compared to last time In the amount budgeted for paving. Mr.
Benton replied that funds are carried forward each year In order
to pave every other year and get a better price because of
larger protects. Mr. Benton stated that Pan American has done
alot of paving for Miami Shores In the past.
In reference to discussion of who controls Miami Shores
roads Mr. Fann stated the County maintained roads are designated
by ordinance but that the County has control over all roads as
far as traffic control. Ms. Stofik Inquired If a road Is
maintained by Miami Shores can the Council determine the width
of the road. Mr. Johnson stated that before any roads are
narrowed the Council should wait until the traffic study Is
complete.
Mr. Spahn moved to award the bid to Pan American
Construction Company In the amount of $137,400. Mr. Canton
seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous In favor.
ITEM *6 DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON COMMUNITY SIGN.
Mr. Johnson reviewed the situation with the community sign,
stating that the only comment came from Chief Zoovas. Mr.
Loffredo stated that the sign was out of place at Its present
location. He said 6th and 96th Is a more appropriate location.
Mr. Spahn stated he would prefer that the sign be In front of
Village Hall. He said It would be out of place In a residential
area. Ms. Stofik disagreed with putting the sign In front of
Village Hall. She said traffic on 2nd Avenue Is not Village
traffic and If a new location Is decided on she would prefer the
Recreation Center area. Mayor Courtney stated that the sign
seemed out of place and was too big for the present location.
He said that the Village Hall or the Recreation Center Is ok
with him. Mr. Canton moved that the Council go back to the
selection committee for the community sign to revisit the
location of the sign because it appears that the majority of the
Council recommends that it not be at the location at 96th and
4th Avenue. Ms. Stofik seconded the motion. Mr. Loffredo asked
for 2 or 3 suggestions from the committee for alternate
locations. The vote was taken for the motion on the floor and
was unanimous In favor.
ITEM *7 REPORT ON LANDSCAPE ORDINANCE.
Mr. Fann stated he and Mr. Laubenthal met the week before
the meeting and it was determined that additional Information
was needed. He said that they need to meet again and that the
ordinance Is very intricate. Ms. Stofik asked If the current
code prevents a resident from having a dead patch of weeds for a
front lawn. Mr. Fann stated that he didn't know if there Is
anything to that effect, but that the new ordinance would
address the subject of dead trees and plants. Mr. Canton asked
whether the new ordinance Is too intricate to be enforced. Mr.
Fann replied that what he Is doing Is reviewing the ordinance to
see If It Is redundant or too complicated.
ITEM *8 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTION 504(b)(2) OF MIAMI SHORES
VILLAGE ZONING ORDINANCE 270, AS AMENDED; REQUIRING PERMIT FOR
DISPLAY OF SIGN ADVERTISING RENTAL, LEASING OR SALE OF LAND;
ESTABLISHING FEE FOR SIGN PERMIT; PROVIDING EFFECTIVE DATE.
Mayor Courtney read the title of the ordinance. Mr. Fann
stated that the ordinance still needs to go to the Planning
Board and be advertised. Ms. Stofik suggested a bond per
broker rather than a permit per sign. She also asked if a
penalty for non compliance could be automatic. Mr. Fann stated
yes after a determination from Code Enforcement. Mr. Canton
stated each offense could have a different penalty. Mr. Spahn
asked what would happen If a person put up their own sign. Mr.
Fann stated that this ordinance would be used to control the use
of a piece of property by someone who doesn't own It. He went
on to say that a bond requires court action for non-compliance.
Ms. Stofik suggested an annual permit fee per entity not per
sign. Mr. Fann stated that it could be done. Mr. Canton asked
If the new ordinance will address "open" signs. Mr. Fann stated
that he could put It In and If they violate the code Mr. Johnson
could deny a permit.
Ms. Stofik suggested for violations the following plan:
1st violation - a small fine
2nd violation - 30 day revocation of permit
3rd violation - 60 day revocation of permit
Mayor Courtney asked Mr. Fann to Include a clause for
penalties. Mr. Fann suggested a higher charge for the next
permit If a permit Is revoked. Ms. Stofik suggested the amount
of $50 per year per broker. Mr. Spahn stated that $50 is too
much for a for sale by owner sign and suggested $10. Mr. Canton
suggested: $10 per year for the permit
$25 after the first revocation
$100 after the second revocation and 30 days wait
$300 after the third revocation and a 90 day waiting
period.
Mr. Spahn stated that the penalty was too high. He said It was
way out of line and suggested:
$10 per year for the permit
$50 for the second permit
$100 for the third permit
Mr. Loffredo stated that quick and certain enforcement was
Important. By consensus of the Council the ordinance was sent
to the Planning and Zoning Board for review.
ITEM *9 DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING RESETTING OF
THE VILLAGE COUNCIL MEETING SCHEDULED FOR TUESDAY, JULY 4TH,
1989 AT 7:30 P.M. AT MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE HALL, RESETTING THE
DATE TO WEDNESDAY, JULY 5TH, 1989, AT 7:30 P.M., AT MIAMI SHORES
VILLAGE HALL AS A SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING.
Mr. Spahn moved to reset the meeting to July 5. Mr. Canton
seconded the motion and the vote was as follows:
Mayor Courtney NO
Ms. Stofik NO
Mr. Spahn Yes
Mr. Loffredo Yes
Mr. Canton Yes
The motion passed. Mr. Loffredo suggested that the meeting be
held on the 5th If there Is business to deal with. Mr. Canton
stated that a month Is too long to wait between meetings.
Mayor Courtney asked the Council to contact Mr. Johnson by
the first of July If they will attend the meeting on July 5th.
ITEM *10 VILLAGE MANAGER'S REPORT. Mr. Johnson reviewed the
report for the Council.
ITEM *11 ANNOUNCEMENTS. Mayor Courtney read the announcements.
ITEM *12 COUNCIL COMMENTS.
Ms. Stofik thanked Mr. Robert Rossi for his service to Miami
Shores.
Mr. Canton spoke about group homes and a stop sign In front of
the Community Center.
Mr. Spahn asked when the budget will be distributed. Ms. Gall
Macdonald replied June 30.
Mr. Loffredo spoke about the pro shop Toss.
Mayor Courtney complimented Mr. Ed Harrigan on the recent Miami
Herald article about him. He also spoke about recycling and
code enforcement.
ITEM *13 PUBLIC COMMENTS
All comments were made by Miami Shores residents.
Mr. Carl Commissiong spoke about barricades, the community sign
and code enforcement.
Mr. Terrell Chambers spoke about real estate signs.
ITEM *14 ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 9:35 p.m..
Attest: Elly F. Johnson
Village Clerk
By:
Scott W. Davis
Deputy Village Clerk
enr; T. Courtn
Ma r