12-02-1975 Regular Meeting REGULAR MEETING
MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE COUNCIL
December 2, 1975
The regular meeting of the Miami Shores Village Council was held at
7:30 p.m. , December 2, 1975, at the Village Hall, with the following Council-
men present:
Mayor Donald W. McIntosh
W. Alfred Davis
Dean R. Claussen
James W. Condit
Jon E. McLeod
Absent: None
Mr. David Peace, Village Manager, and Mr. Richard Lund, Village
Attorney, were also present.
The meeting was opened with an invocation given by Rev. Matthew
Kerestes of the Advent Lutheran Church, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
Minutes of the special meeting held on November 11, 1976, were approved
by motion made by Mr. Davis, seconded by Mr. Condit and passed.
Minutes of the regular meeting of November 18, 1976, were also
approved as written by motion made by Mr. Davis, seconded by Mr. McLeod
and passed.
Opening of bids for street sweeper.
The following bids were opened and recorded:
H. F. MASON EQUIPMENT CORP. $31, 342. 00
FLA. MUNICIPAL SALES CO. 24, 429. 00
Mr. McLeod moved that the bids be sent back to the Village Manager
for a recommendation at the next meeting. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Condit and carried.
12/2/75
-2-
Council determination is regard to Police negotiations.
Mayor McIntosh reported that a public hearing was held on November
19th, at the request of the P. B. A. for further consideration of (1) wages,
(2) longevity pay, (3) sick leave and (4) pension plan. The Council took these
items under advisement and set a meeting on November 24th for further consider-
ation. After receipt of a telegram from P. B. A. attorney Slesnick, further
discussion on the items was cancelled.
Mr. Condit stated that the Council had spent many hours in trying to
come to an equitable basis on wages and benefits; in view of the fact that it went
to arbitration and the award confirmed the Council's offer, he moved that the
Council again offer the P. B. A. a last offer in order to reach an agreement and
if this offer is refused all negotiations for the current year be closed. The motion
was seconded by Mr. Davis. Mr. McLeod read an article from the Miami Herald
concerning the County Police arbitration in which a recommendation was made for
binding arbitration instead of advisory arbitration, and he added that he felt the
Council should go along with the total recommendation made by the Special
Master.
Mayor McIntosh reviewed the points in question: wages - 5% offer was
made and has been paid since October 1st. This raise with those of the last two
years has averaged 10% over each of the last three years. On longevity, Mr.
McIntosh asked the Council to consider 2% after 7 years, 5% after ten years
and 10% after 15 and up. Sick leave - should stay the same but review of the
policy should be given serious study for all employees. On the pension plan,
Pension Board
we cannot discriminate or change plans. However, the Ge recently approved
3% interest to be paid on refunded contributions, effective January 1st. Mayor
12/2/75
-3-
McIntosh also asked the Council to consider some reimbursement for educational
courses taken by any employee. Mr. Claussen moved to amend the previous
motion, that the Council accept the Master's ruling with the exception of
longevity pay for all officers except the Chief of Police. This amendment was
not accepted by Mr. Condit because he felt all employees should be treated
alike with regard to longevity. Mr. Condit's original motion was then voted on
as follows;
Mr. McLeod Yes
Mr. Condit Yes
Mr. Davis No
Mr. Claussen No
Mr. McIntosh No
The motion failed on a 2/3 vote.
Mr. Claussen moved that the police be offered longevity pay at 2% after
7 years, 5% after 10 years and 10% after 15 years and up, and reject the other
three items under discussion. The motion was seconded by Mr. McLeod and
passed 4/1 with Mr. Condit dissenting.
Telephone proposal.
Mr. Gerald Cardelli, Edward Paganini and Bruce Ferraro of Southern
Bell, presented a proposal, originated by Councilman McLeod, for a central
phone system located at the Country Club. It was suggested by Mr. McLeod that
more information be secured on hours spent on the phone, number of calls, etc.
Administration recommendation on Tennis Club hitting wall bids.
Mr. Peace recommended that the low bid of the Garan Co. in the
amount of $4200. 00 be accepted. Mr. Claussen moved that action on this item
be tabled. Mr. McLeod seconded the motion and added that based on the list of
bills due at the Club and the cash balance as of November 30, 1975, there is
12/2/75
-4-
absolutely no money for this item. The motion carried unanimously.
Administration recommendation on golf course turf sweeper bids.
Since there was only one bid received, from DeBra Turf & Industrial
Equip. , in the amount of $2, 595. 00, it was recommended that it be accepted.
Mr. Claussen moved that action be tabled on this bid. The motion was seconded
by Mr. McLeod and passed 4/1 with Mayor McIntosh dissenting.
Administration recommendation on bids for carpeting the ladies
locker room.
Mr. Peace recommended that the low bid of Harry Rich at $3, 356. 00
be accepted. Mr. Claussen moved that this be tabled. The motion was seconded
by Mr. Condit and carried.
After further discussion Mr. Davis moved that all bids be rejected and
that we advertize for new bids on the three items listed on the agenda as 5, 6, &
7, for bids to be received on December 16th. The motion was seconded by
Mr. Claussen and carried 4/1 with Mr. Condit dissenting.
Report on F. P. L. franchise and utility tax coding.
Mayor McIntosh reported on the calls received from the article in the
Village Hall News and presented a map showing areas of the city that were
excluded from the route numbers furnished by F. P. L. , and asked for Council
authorization to proceed further and request an audit of the franchise rebate.
This was authorized by motion made by Mr. Davis, seconded by Mr. McLeod
and carried unanimously.
Village Manager's report.
(1) Mr. Peace reported that he has had requests to remove trees
on public property at the property owners expense, but in view of the established
12/2/75
-5-
policy of not removing good trees, he asked for direction of Council. Mr.
Claussen moved that this be referred to Henry Boliek and the Village Manager
to use their own good judgment for decision. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Condit and passed unanimously.
(2) Concerning an invoice from O'Neal Septic Tank in the amount of
$2, 196. 00, Mr. Peace reported that a new drain field had been installed at the
Country Club, without knowledge or authorization of the Village Manager or Club
Manager. Mr. Peace asked for authorization to pay the bill. Mr. Claussen
stated he would make a report on this installation, which was done on an emergency
basis, and moved that we pay the bill. The motion was seconded by Mr. Davis
and passed unanimously.
Village Attorney's report.
Mr. Lund stated that he would write a resolution for the Dade
Handicapped Committee.
Mr. McLeod asked for a date schedule on the following items;
(1) Relocation of floor plan and remodeling of the Village Hall,
and suggested that the Village Manager get with the Planning & Zoning Board
for a complete re-evaluation of the floor plan of the Village Hall.
(2) Study of the maintenance area and facilities. Mr. Peace stated
that this has been referred to the Planning Board.
(3) Job descriptions, due January 1st. Mr. Peace reported that
he is drawing up these descriptions.
(4) Surplus Village property - Mr. McLeod asked if all lists had
been made up, with exception of the Public Works Dept. , that a recommendation
12/2/75
-6-
be made to Council on December 16th as to disposition.
(5) Library flooring - Mr. McLeod asked the Village Manager if
he had made repairs to the flooring of the library with the money allocated in
the budget. Inasmuch as Mr. Peace did not think he had the authority to do
this, Mr. McLeod moved that the Village Manager take the authority to do
whatever is necessary to repair a building that belongs to Miami Shores. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Davis and passed unanimously.
Mayor McIntosh brought up the drainage problems and asked the
Village Manager to set up a priority list to act on requests. He further requested
that the drainage problems be taken to the Planning & Zoning Board for
recommendation and priority.
The meeting adjourned at 9:15 p. m .
Village Clerk
APPROVED:
l
M�y o r