05-14-1946 Regular Meeting MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING
MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE COUNCIL
MAY 14, 1946
The regular monthly meeting of the Miami Shores Village
Council was held at 7:30 PM May 14, 1946. All members of the
Council were present. Mr. Thomas Anderson, Village Attorney,
was also presents
Minutes of the regular meeting of April 9, 1946 were
read and approved.
Village Attorney Anderson reported that, in response to
the direction of the Council at its April 9, 1946 meeting,
as transmitted to him by the Village Manager, he had communicated
to the Florida East Coast Railway the desire of the Council
w
for reduction in speed of trains passing through the Village
and installation of safety gates at the three crossings within
the Village. Mr• Gaddis and Mr. Wahl, representing the
Railway, then appeared before the Council. Correspondence read
by Mr. Gaddis indicated difficulty in obtaining critical
materials required in manufacture of crossing protection
equipment. He offered his assurance, however, that as soon as
such materials, which have been ordered, are available, safety
gates will be erected at the three crossings in question.
Questioned by the Mayor and other Council members on the speed
of the FEC trains, Mr. Gaddis admitted their speed was in excess
of 30 miles per hour, and was again cautioned with reference to
reduction in speed. He said if the Council were to adopt an
tog
203
-2-
ordinance requiring the FEC to stop the train whistles,
the Railway would discontinue the praeticee
Mr* Calvin We McCutehen appeared before the Council with
reference to communication addressed to him by the Village
Manager, in accordance with direction of the Council at
April 9 meeting that keepers of pigeons within the Shores be
ordered to dispose of such stock. Mrs* McKay, 141 N.W. 98th
Street, neighbor of Air* McCutehen, also appeared in further
reference to her previous complaint about his pigeons, stating
that, though no proof can be offered, she believes the pigeons
draw flies, and that the numbers of flies about the house
cause her concern for the health of her small child.
Mr* Reynolds moved that the matter be taken under advise-
ment, for further discussion at next Council meeting, on the
understanding that in the meantime, through survey by and
consultation with an expert on the matter, effort will be made
to determine if there is an over-abundance of flies in the
immediate vicinity of Mr* McCutchen's residence, and on the
further understanding that Mr* McCutchen may retain his pigeons
while the investigation is in progress* Mr* McKee seconded
the motion, which passed unanimously.
Letter from 7r* Thomas S* Griggs was read, requesting permit
for alterations in his home at 150 N*E* 96th Street for purpose
of converting a portion thereof into his professional office,
such permission having been denied by the Planning Board* In
the discussion thich followed, reference was made to the litiga-
tion in which the building at that address is presently involved*
The Village Attorney stated it as his opinion that the matter in
909
205
-3-
which Dr. Griggs is concerned has no connection with such
litigation; that if Dr. Griggs is living in this dwelling as
his home, he would, under the provisions of :Section Z6-5 of
the Zoning Ordinance, be permitted to carry on in that
building the practice of medicine, provided no person or
persons other than members of his own household are employed
by him in such practice. Lir. Griggs stated he has no
employees.
Mr. Reynolds moved that the Planning Board be instructed
to issue permit, as requested by Dr. Griggs, in accordance
with the provisions of Section Z6-5 of the Village Zoning
Ordinance. Mr. Parish seconded the motion, which was carried
by four-fifths vote, Mr. McKee dissenting.
Mr. Paul J. Kinney presented to the Council a petition,
signed by 23 persons whom he identified as builders in Miami
Shores, for relief from that portion of the present building
code requiring concrete grade beam, so as to permit cement
block grade beam with a four-inch cap. Mr. Kinney also pre-
sented letter from Chief Building Inspector, City of Miami,
certifying that the Miami Building Code does not call for
grade beams to be poured except for engineerfs design for
major structures or building in low muck ground or new fill,
as well as letter from District Director, FHA, stating that
construction of the type covered by the petition is considered
good and acceptable for insured mortgages on typical construction
in this area. Mayor McCaffrey and Mr. McKee stated their op-
position to the proposed change on the grounds it represented
no improvement in the present building code.
_S09
207
-4=
After some discussion, Mr. Parish moved that the present
building code be modified to permit use of 12-inch block on
bearing walls, from outside to inside, and eight-inch block
on non-bearing walls, except in places where there is filled
or soft ground, and that the ordinance be thus redrawn by the
Village Attorney and passed by the Council. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Reynolds and carried by three-fifths vote,
Messrs. McCaffrey and McKee dissenting. It was the decision
of the Council that, pending redrawing of the Building
Ordinance, construction on the revised basis would be per-
mitted, and the Village Building Inspector was instructed by
the Mayor to approve future plans on such basis.
With further reference to Ordinance No. 154, granting
franchise to Peoples Water & Gas Company, the Village Attorney
requested approval of the Council to bond in amount of $159000
for proper performance by the Company. This approval was given
by the Council.
Mrs. Cora M. Fleshman, owner of Lot 23, Block 10, Miami
Shores Section 1, which is a lot with 56-foot frontage,
requested permit to build on said lot, which she had purchased
in 1924. Mayor McCaffrey informed her the proper procedure is
to submit the matter to the Planning Board. Should the request
be denied by that Board, the matter may again be brought before
the Council at its neat meeting for final decision.
The Council discussed application of Mr. Co Fe Wheeler
for permit to erect 12 a 20 portable garage for temporary
servants' quarters at 124 N.E. 96th Street. As such construction
I9
i
I 211
�I
4
is contrary to the present building code, Mr. McKee moved
that the permit be refused. Mr. Parish seconded the motion,
which carried unanimously.
The Village Attorney submitted Ordinance No* 156 s
amending the present Zoning Ordinance No. 92 with respect to
definition and application of the term "residence" as applied
to a single-family residence. Mr. Kilburn moved that the
ordinance be adopted; the motion was seconded by Mr. Parish
and unanimously carried.
Mr. Anderson also submitted letter dated May 14, 1946
addressed to the Village Manager, serving as formal opinion
that the Council has authority to review decisions of the
Board of Adjustments and, further, that the Council is the
only legislative body which has the final right to determine
the use to which property in the Village may be put. This
opinion was accepted by the Council for the record.
Question of whether or not the Village is to take steps
to recover legal expenses incurred in the American Legion
litigation was discussed. The Village Attorney stated that#
as a matter of legal duty, the Council is obligated to make
the effort to obtain the amount of such expense. The matter
was also discussed briefly with Mr. Marion Arnold, the new
Commander of the Wm9 Brockway Post, and the suggestion made
that if and when the Post is successful in disposing of its
lots,, arrangement could probably be made for settling this
expense item. It was the decision of the Council that the
matter be held in abeyance.
Ordinance 156A (Sidewalk Ordinance) as submitted by
Village Attorney, was unanimously adopted upon motion by Mr. 9 8 [
18�
-6-•
Kilburn, seconded by Mr. Reynolds.
The Village Manager read letter from Mr. A. E. Fuller,
Executive Vice President, Pan American Bank of Miami, eon-
firming that, to insure the Village of availability of cash
presuming purchase by the Village of U.S. Government securities,
the Board of Directors of that bank have formally authorized a
loan up to $1.00,000 to the Village, to be secured by a like
principal amount of Series "C" U.S. Treasury Savings Notes,
at the same rate of interest accruing on the notes, to mature
at the earliest redemption date of such notes. Mr. Anderson
stated his opinion that the Council has not the legal right
to put out the Village money at interest in investments not
immediately convertible into cash, but that this difficulty is
eliminated by the provisions of the Pan American Bank letter.
Mr. Parish moved that the Village Manager be authorized
to invest $100,000 Golf Course Improvement Funds in Series "C"
U.S. Treasury Savings Notes paying 6/10% interest. Mr. McKee
seconded the motion, which was carried unanimously.
The sewer project was discussed, with particular reference
to obtaining services of qualified engineer to complete applica-
tion forms for federal funds to aid in the project. Both Mr.
McKee and the Village Manager reported on their preliminary
negotiations to this end. It was the decision of the Council
that the Village Manager continue such negotiations on the basis
of a fee to the engineer of approximately $300 to X400 (the
exact amount to be left to Mr. McCallts discretion) for perform-
ing the necessary calculations to complete the application,
such feet however, to be waived by the consulting engineer if
and when he is awarded contract for the project.
98T
181
t
-7-
April bills were submitted to the Council. Mr. Parish
moved that such bills, in total amount of $4,719.98v be
approved and paid. Mr. Kilburn seconded the motion, which
carried unanimously.
Mr. Parish moved that expenditure of up to $250 for
entertainment of the Police Chiefs Association of Dade County
be authorized. The motion was seconded by Mr. Kilburn and
unanimously carried.
The Council adjourned at 10:50 PM*
c
age anage an ler
Approved:
OST
179