2022-04-21 MINUTES1
EDUCATION ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES
April 21, 2022
9900 NE 2ND AVE
6:00 PM
The meeting was called to order by Mr. Netto at 6:08 PM with the following members present:
Ms. Kristen Feuer
Ms. Dana Vignale
Ms. Sylvie Duerkop
Ms. Tiffany Anderson
Ms. Leslie Fraser
Mr. Joseph Paulino
Mr. Antonio Netto (via phone- beginning of meeting)
Dr. Michael Lewis- Central Region Superintendent
Mr. Esmond Scott- Village Manager
Also present: Ms. Ysabely Rodriguez, Village Clerk
Ms. Brenda Swain, MSES Principal
Mr. Daniel Diaz, MSES Vice Principal
PTA Executive Members: Andrea Fleury, Sarah Vahan
1. CALL TO ORDER: 6:08PM
2. ROLL CALL: Ysabely Rodriguez took roll call at 6:08PM
3. PUBLIC COMMENTS- None
4. APPROVAL OF THE FEBRUARY and MARCH MINUTES: Motion by Tiffany Anderson and Second by
Joseph Paulino. Motion passed.
5. CONSIDERATIONS
• UPDATE BY MSES ADMINISTRATION: Brenda Swain- School in midst of construction and
actual building visible by NE 6th, HVAC system in office replaced, foundation cracks filled
in, rest room taking shape. Much construction will be finished over the summer. The
school will not be a summer school site. Possible ending date for construction is October-
December, 2022. Construction Recap: entire new HVAC system, painting outside and
inside, new roof for cafeteria and media center, ADA compliant restrooms in pre-K
building. Cambridge program is in full effect school-wide. Planning an event for the end
of school year and will update the board at the next meeting. Safety and security of
building: very limited covid cases, all students in the building with very few absences. In
February, MSES was one of the top ten schools that increased attendance during the
second grading period. MSES is at 84% capacity.
• DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING 2022 MSES PARENT SURVEY
Update provided by Dana Vignale. Ms. Vignale thanked everyone for attendance. Ms.
Vignale wants to bring many resources to the school which we have access to, to raise the
quality of the school. How do we bring our residents back? This was one of the main
purposes of the survey. Ms. Vignale asked would it be helpful to have a meeting between
Mr. Scott and the School district so that everyone knows their respective roles and
accountability. The concern is the Village has proffered funds and the board wants to be
2
kept apprised of the progress. Ms. Vignale stated Ms. Swain’s report tonight is very helpful
and we want it to be communicated Village-wide. We really want to do what we can to
help spread the word on the great work happening at MSES.
Looking at the survey report- looking at students assigned to the MSES boundary only
57% attend. The question is why are parents choosing to leave the boundary school when
we have an incredible school right here? Ms. Vignale compared the school to Pinecrest
(due to similar demographics) and 86.4% attend Pinecrest. When Ms. Vignale compared
these outcomes – Miami Shores families are not attending the neighborhood school
which is what prompted the survey. The survey received 164 responses. Looking at
comments and feedback, Ms. Vignale does not feel the community knows the great work
happening at MSES. Ms. Vignale posed a question to Dr. Lewis regarding the new charter
school, Mater Academy at the former Johnson & Whales campus.
o Response by Dr. Lewis– Dr. Lewis stated he agrees with the importance of
working together and requests increased communication and invitations to
meetings so that we may work collaboratively. Dr. Lewis was at initial onset of
Cambridge at MSES and wants to work collaboratively to enhance the community
school. Very proud of MDCPS choice district. Dr. Lewis indicated that Pinecrest is
not a good comparison because it is currently nationally recognized, but agrees
that MSES has so much to offer. Dr. Lewis stated the District will make it a priority
to have someone from the Region and someone from the school at all meetings.
Dr. Lewis requested all invitations/communication be sent to Martha Montaner-
because this is an intergovernmental affair. Ms. Montaner is the direct contact
person when it comes to EAB’s and the EAB can also request specific data from
her.
o Ms. Duerkop stated that the PTA is implementing a testimonial project for the
benefit of residents who do not attend the school - The idea is to have Ms. Swain
and Mr. Diaz speak about the Cambridge program and provide updates on the
construction. The testimonials would be on the MSES Website and they would
like to have it elsewhere.
o Ms. Swain discussed the in-person school tour and the virtual tour.
o Ms. Fraser discussed the need for friendliness at MSES since Miami Shores is the
“friendly village” as well as the ongoing need for marketing.
o Dr. Lewis stated he worked at the Miami Shores Publix in his youth and holds the
community in high regards. He acknowledged the great work of the PTA. Dr. Lewis
stated that for the next EAB meeting he would pull the data for the boundary
including the total number of school-aged children and where they attend and
how many attend MSES.
o Ms. Vignale discussed how physical school tours can begin again next year earlier
than this year since private school deposits are typically due the first week in
January. Ms. Vignale also suggested that when the new construction is finished,
we could plan a ribbon cutting ceremony and make it a big event, inviting
everyone from the community to come and see the new building. Ms. Vignale
also suggested a strategic marketing idea to invite local realtors to the school due
3
to the fact that buyers always ask realtors about the local schools. This would be
a very strategic way to reach residents. Ms. Swain responded that local realtor
Robert Borne has always been very supportive of MSES.
o Ms. Duerkop asked whether there is a resource for a more dedicated marketing
team to help with the school website and general communication.
o Ms. Andrea Fleury stated the PTA is considering the idea of a smaller marketing
committee for the sole purpose of marketing given the many other issues Ms.
Swain and Mr. Diaz have to focus on daily.
o Regarding the open house, Dr. Lewis stated these events are done by the District
and a ribbon cutting ceremony is actually a requirement of the Office of Facilities,
organized by Mr. Robert Perez. It is not an expectation but a requirement.
Regarding marketing, Dr. Lewis stated that the majority of schools normally hire
a private entity. Ms. Swain indicated we have someone at the school who works
on the website.
o Ms. Anderson suggested the use of the newsletter of Miami Shores for an MSES
corner.
o Ms. Vignale posed the question on when to close the survey and how to counter
the false perception that non-attendees have as well as comparing the survey to
the school climate survey. Ms. Swain stated we will not have results to the climate
survey by May.
o Ms. Feuer made a motion to close the survey on May 30 after the PTA movie night
and Miami Shores Green Day. Seconded by Mr. Paulino. Motion passed
unanimously.
o Ms. Vignale and Ms. Duerkop addressed the ongoing concern that there is a
territory of Miami Shores assigned to Hubert O. Sibley school boundary instead
of MSES. It was discussed that prior to the Cambridge program, Mr. Benton was
going to work with the School District to incorporate that small area into the MSE
boundary. Ms. Vignale stated the Board would need to revisit this issue and look
at minutes to see if there was action we should have taken, or was ever taken on
this issue.
o Dr. Lewis stated he would also reach out to North Region Office (Dr. Cabrera-
North Region Superintendent) and bring us in but stated the process takes place
in October. He stated we need to reach out to Dr. Cabrera as it will impact her
region. That correspondence should come from our Village Manager and we also
need to include Martha Montaner. The first step would be to let her know the
intent so that she can bring Dr. Cabrera into the conversation since it will
negatively impact the North region.
o Mr. Esmond Scott, Village Manager, stated the will directly handle this matter.
o Ms. Ysabely Rodriguez stated that the former village manager was given that
directive and he did send a letter but to the wrong contact.
• DISCUSSION & POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING THE EAB COLLABORATING WITH MSES PTA
ON GREEN DAY, APRIL 30.
o Ms. Andrea Fleury and Ms. Sarah Vahan discussed the representation of the
school at Green Day and the goal to have families come out and meet the type of
4
people attending MSES, show smiling faces and encourage our MSES families to
come out, encourage all students to wear school T-shirts as it would be a nice way
for the school to show our school spirit and for Green Day attendees to see how
many families are attending MSES. Stated that Mr. Antonio Netto wanted to
come and represent the EAB. Ms. Swain will be in attendance as well.
6. NEW BUSINESS:
• DISCUSSION & POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING UPCOMING MIAMI SHORES COMMUNITY
ALLIANCE GRANT FUNDING REQUEST.
o Ms. Ysabely Rodriguez stated the deadline for the grant is next week 4/30/22 and
began filling out the application but wanted direction from the Board, specifically
as to the proposed use of the funds.
o Ms. Swain suggested funds could go toward the continuation of the hedge
project. The PTA used the donated EAB funds from the GoFundMe page and also
raised additional funds and found irrigation already in place but would like to
continue the hedge along the 105th street perimeter of the school. This is the area
where the students play so it is important to create privacy for the children.
o There was consensus to continue with the application for the community alliance
grant.
• DISCUSSION & POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING THE EAB DONATING $600 TO MSES PTA TO
ASSIST WITH TEACHER APPRECIATION LUNCHEON
o There was consensus to transfer money to the PTA by Ms. Duerkop.
o The PTA has an entire week of events planned in honor of teacher appreciation
including a massage therapist on campus, two food events. One event is a taco
lunch costing approximately $700. Tinta Y Café is sponsoring a breakfast and
Pebble & Vine is providing gifts for the teachers. During the Spa Day, teachers will
also receive self-care gifts.
7. ADJOURNMENT: 7:25 Motion to adjourn by Mr. Anderson. Meeting adjourned.