2017-05-16 MIN
Miami Shores Village
10050 N.E.2nd Avenue
Miami Shores, Florida 33138
Barbara Estep, MMC
Village Clerk
MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
The Miami Shores Village Council held their regularly scheduled Council Meeting on Tuesday, May 16,
2017 in the Council Chambers of Village Hall. The Meeting was called to order at 6:30 PM with the
following individuals present:
PRESENT: MacAdam Glinn
Sean Brady
Alice Burch
Jonathan Meltz
Steven Zelkowitz
ALSO PRESENT: Tom Benton, Village Manager
Barbara Estep, Village Clerk
Richard Sarafan, Village Attorney
CONSIDERATIONS
1) VILLAGE CLERK Barbara A. Estep
A) APPROVAL OF THE MAY 2, 2017 COUNCIL MEETING AND MAY 8, 2017
COUNCIL WORKSHOP MINUTES.
Councilwoman Burch moved approval of the May 2 and May 8, 2017 Minutes as presented.
Councilman Zelkowitz seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
B) APPOINTMENT OF ONE COUNCIL MEMBER TO THE GENERAL EMPLOYEE
PENSION BOARD.
Mayor Glinn volunteered to serve on the General Employee Pension Board. The consensus of the
Council was to appoint Mayor Glinn to the General Employee Pension Board.
C) APPOINTMENT OF TWO COUNCIL MEMBERS TO THE POLICE RETIREMENT
PENSION BOARD.
Councilwoman Burch and Councilman Meltz volunteered to serve on the Police Retirement
Pension Board. The consensus of the Council was to appoint Councilman Meltz and
Councilwoman Burch to the Police Retirement Pension Board.
D) APPOINTMENT OF A COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE AND AN ALTERNATE
REPRESENTATIVE TO THE MIAMI-DADE LEAGUE OF CITIES.
Councilman Zelkowitz volunteered to serve as the Village’s representative to the Miami-Dade
League of Cities, with Councilwoman Burch volunteering to be the alternate representative. The
consensus of the Council was to appoint Councilman Zelkowitz and Councilwoman Burch as the
representative and alternate representative to the Miami-Dade League of Cities respectively.
E) APPOINTMENT OF A COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE TO THE FLORIDA LEAGUE
OF CITIES.
Mayor Glinn indicated that he would like to serve as the Village’s representative for the Florida
League of Cities. The consensus of the Council was to appoint Mayor Glinn to represent the
Village at the Florida League of Cities.
F) APPOINTMENT OF A CONCIL REPRESENTATIVE TO THE GREEN CORRIDOR
DISTRICT BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
Vice Mayor Brady volunteered to serve on the Green Corridor District Board of Directors. It was
the consensus of the Council to appoint Vice Mayor Brady to serve as the Village’s representative
to the Green Corridor District Board of Directors.
G) A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI SHORES VILLAGE COUNCIL AUTHORIZING
THE CURRENT MAYOR TO BE SUBSTITUTED FOR THE PRIOR MAYOR, AS
SIGNATORY FOR APPLICABLE VILLAGE BANK ACCOUNTS, AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
Ms. Estep read the caption of the resolution into the record. Councilman Zelkowitz moved to
approve the resolution as presented. Vice Mayor Brady seconded the motion and the vote was
unanimous in favor of the motion.
H) APPOINTMENT OF CANDIDATE YSABELY RODRIGUEZ TO THE POSITION OF
VILLAGE CLERK.
Ms. Estep introduced Ms. Ysabely Rodriguez, noting that the Council had conducted a Council
Workshop during which the Council met and interviewed Ms. Rodriguez for the position of Village
Clerk. Ms. Rodriguez briefly spoke on her own behalf. Councilman Zelkowitz advised that he has
worked with Ms. Rodriguez in connection with her work for Hallandale Beach and his service as
the City’s CRA Attorney.
Resident Al Crespo spoke about the position being a Charter Officer position and the need for the
Clerk to be an independent position and not serving as the Manager’s Executive Assistant.
Councilwoman Burch moved to appoint Ms. Ysabely Rodriguez as the Village Clerk, upon the
retirement of Ms. Estep. Vice Mayor Brady seconded the motion and the vote was unanimous in
favor of the motion.
2) VILLAGE ATTORNEY Richard Sarafan
A) A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND VILLAGE COUNCIL OF MIAMI SHORES
VILLAGE, FLORIDA, AFFIRMING APPROVAL OF A “WAIVER OF PLAT” FOR THE
PROPERTY KNOWN AS LOTS 22 & 23, BLOCK 18, AMENDED PLAT OF MIAMI
SHORES VILLAGE SECTION NO. 1, TO ALLOW INDIVIDUAL PARCELS TO BE
DIVIDED BY “WAIVER OF PLAT” IN CONNECTION WITH THE VILLAGE
DOWNTOWN SEWAGE PROJECT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY, PROVIDING
FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Ms. Estep read the caption of the resolution into the record. Mr. Sarafan offered an explanation of
the need for the resolution which provides for a waiver of plat of Village property containing
equipment related to the downtown sewer project. Mr. Sarafan recommends that the Council
approve the resolution. Councilman Zelkowitz moved to adopt the proposed Resolution as
presented. Councilwoman Burch seconded the motion.
Resident Al Crespo requested additional information regarding the project. Mayor Glinn reminded Mr.
Crespo that questions were not responded to during the comment section and invited him to speak with
Mr. Benton or a member of the Council following the meeting.
Mayor Glinn called for the vote on the motion, which was unanimous in favor of the motion.
B) DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING 85 N.W. 103RD STREET.
Mr. Sarafan provided background information regarding the property and its status, i.e. an existing
judgement, accruing code liens, special assessment liens and attorney’s fees. Mr. Sarafan indicated that
there have been ongoing negotiations with a perspective buyer and that a settlement under the Code’s
provisions for a “reasonable accommodation” is available. The buyer proposes to pay $150,000 to the
Village and commit to a date certain regarding completion of the needed repairs on the property. In
response to concerns expressed by Councilman Zelkowitz at a previous meeting, Mr. Sarafan indicated
that there are attorney’s and broker fees to be paid by the seller which he believes will net the sellers
very little, if any profit. Mr. Sarafan outlined the various scenarios available regarding the property’s
disposition and stated his belief that the current offer is the best offer and best alternative for the
Village and stated his recommendation that the Village approve the settlement proposal.
Councilman Zelkowitz asked about adding language to the settlement agreement which would provide
for forfeiture of the buyer’s deposit to the Village if the sale falls through as well as language that
stipulates that should the purchase contract be amended and the purchase price increased, the
additional funds come to the Village rather than the sellers. Council Members offered their opinions of
the settlement proposal, the condition of the property and its prominent location so close to an
entranceway into the Village, and their concern regarding the current owner profiting from the sale.
The perspective buyer was present and spoke to the Council regarding his desire to purchase and repair
the property. He stated that the purchase price is $190,000.
Following the discussions, Councilwoman Burch moved to accept the proposal and offer described by
Attorney Sarafan and to the extent possible, Councilman Zelkowitz’s amendments to the settlement
agreement as discussed. Councilman Zelkowitz seconded the motion.
Resident Al Crespo spoke of the impact of dilapidated homes and that perhaps the Village should re-
visit the timing of obtaining judgements and moving to mitigate the non-compliant properties.
Mayor Glinn called for the vote on the motion which was unanimous in favor of the motion.
3) VILLAGE COUNCIL Councilman Jonathan Meltz
A) DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING MOVING PUBLIC COMMENTS
TO THE TOP OF THE AGENDA.
Councilman Meltz offered his rational in calling for moving public comment to the beginning of the
agenda rather than opening the floor for public comment on each individual item contained on the
agenda. He cited other municipalities that conduct their meetings in similar fashion and the fairness of
allowing residents the opportunity to speak at the beginning of the meeting so that they do not have to
wait until the item is heard by the Council. He expressed his belief that his proposal gives residents a
better option in that residents will know they will be heard early in the meeting. Following his
statement, Councilman Meltz moved to hear public comment at the beginning of each Council
Meeting. Councilman Zelkowitz seconded the motion.
Resident Al Crespo voiced his opposition to the proposal and provided his reasoning for his
opposition. He urged the Council not to pass the measure.
Council Members spoke of positive points associated with hearing public comments at the start of the
meeting, and Councilman Zelkowitz shared that in many cities, residents are required to submit their
names prior to the meeting in order to address the elected body. Subsequent to these discussions, the
vote was taken and was unanimous in favor of the motion.
4) VILLAGE MANAGER Tom Benton
A) PRESENTATION, DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING THE P3
REPORT FROM RMA.
Mr. Benton introduced Mr. Kevin Crowder from the RMA firm. Mr. Crowder presented a power point
presentation which highlighted the information contained in RMA’s draft report on the various options
available to the Village with respect to a P3 (Public Private Partnership) relationship. Mr. Crowder
reviewed three possible scenarios which included different configurations for the development of the
Village owned parcels located on the east side of N.E. 2nd Avenue and where the Village Hall, Police
Department and the 9900 building are currently located. Mr. Crowder spoke of the lengthy process to
initiate a P3 agreement and indicated a number of steps which he suggested would be appropriate in the
future, including Council Workshop meetings to discuss details regarding the various scenarios as well
as Public Outreach meetings.
Council Members asked for clarification on certain items and stressed that there was no immediate
action contemplated or being taken with respect to the P3 idea. The Council voiced their support of
conducting a Council Workshop and reaching out to the development community to see if there is any
interest in the concept.
Resident Al Crespo requested a copy of the Power Point presentation.
5) ANNOUNCEMENTS
Ms. Estep read the announcements.
6) PUBLIC COMMENTS (3 Minute Time Limit Per Speaker)
Al Crespo Mr. Crespo spoke of recent e-mails sent to the Council regarding the Country Club
lease agreement.
Victor Bruce Mr. Bruce congratulated the Council Members and urged them to continue to support
RMA’s initiatives.
Myrtha Wroy Ms. Wroy welcomed the new Council and spoke about the defeated bond issue for a
new community center.
John Farina Mr. Farina also congratulated the newly seated Council and spoke of the
neighborhood communication forums.
Councilman Zelkowitz left the meeting at this time.
7) COUNCIL COMMENTS
Jonathan Meltz Councilman Meltz thanked everyone for their attendance and is looking
forward to a great term.
Alice Burch Councilwoman Burch spoke of a reception at the Library in honor of Mrs.
Bolton who has made a donation in the amount of $50,000 towards the Children’s Wing. She also
spoke of the drive-through mailboxes that were once again removed from N.E. 98th Street.
Sean Brady Vice Mayor Brady thanked those in attendance and spoke of the letter
received from resident Kim Flowers and the County’s impact fees for new businesses in the Village.
MacAdam Glinn Mayor Glinn thanked the Chamber’s Downtown Advisory Committee and
spoke of the upcoming Board appointments for the Library and Charter School Boards. He also
spoke of the Village’s Memorial Day ceremony.
8) ADJOURNMENT
The May 16, 2017 Council meeting was adjourned at 8:20 PM.
______________________________
Barbara A. Estep, MMC
Village Clerk